From historic struggles to the Super Bowl: The New England Patriots' impossible turnaround

New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel holds the trophy after the AFC Championship NFL football game against the Denver Broncos
New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel holds the trophy after the AFC Championship NFL football game against the Denver BroncosČTK / AP / Ashley Landis

This weekend, the New England Patriots will contest their 12th Super Bowl, but not long ago, they couldn't have seemed further from doing so.

It was the evening of the last Sunday in 2025. The New England Patriots had just returned home from New York City after dismantling their division rival, the Jets, in a dominant 42-10 win. Yet there was no celebration. Everybody was glued to their phone.

The AFC East title was still undecided. Philadelphia were battling Buffalo, and a Bills loss would hand the division crown to New England.

As the Patriots waited, anticipation turned into tension. Late in the fourth quarter, the Eagles clung to a 13–6 lead, and Buffalo mounted one last drive - touchdown! 13-12. With five seconds left, the Bills lined up for a two-point conversion.

Josh Allen dropped back and fired a pass toward the end zone - incomplete! The Patriots erupted in joy and excitement. The next few minutes were filled with hugs, fist bumps, and high fives. The team just secured the divisional crown.

The moment highlighted an incredible milestone in New England’s historic turnaround. Just one season earlier, they had won only four games. The year before that? Another 4–13 finish. No division titles. No playoff success. A franchise once synonymous with dominance had fallen into irrelevance. 

For over 20 years, the Patriots were nearly an untouchable powerhouse terrorising the league. Other teams rarely had answers for Bill Belichick & Tom Brady. This duo and the rest of the team functioned like a well-oiled machine. Six Super Bowl wins and nine total Super Bowl appearances. A dynasty unlike any other. But nothing lasts forever. 

After a disappointing 2019 season, Brady left and signed with the Buccaneers. The struggles began. The Patriots missed the playoffs the following year, lost in the Divisional Round the season after, then completely missed the postseason again in 2022. 

A disastrous 2023 campaign and an upsetting 4-13 record ended Belichick’s long ride with the Patriots, as he and the organisation mutually parted ways.

It marked the official ending of the greatest dynasty in the NFL. The times when New England bullied their opponents were long gone, and a change was much needed. The Patriots needed a new spark. The roster was a mess, the culture was fractured, and frustration was overboiling. New England desperately needed to rebuild the team to become a contender again.

The organisation first turned inward, promoting linebacker coach Jerod Mayo to head coach. Mayo was a former Patriot – he spent eight years in the NFL and won a Super Bowl in 2008. He was supposed to bring back a winning mentality and physical toughness. The issue? Mayo had no head coaching experience, and it showed.

Under the leadership of the former franchise player, the Patriots started the season 1-6. At one point, they lost seven straight home games – the longest losing streak since 1993.

The hopes for a rebuild quickly disappeared. Instead, the franchise hit a new rock bottom. The Patriots' roster was somehow even worse than the previous year. They were underperforming, and the media was ripping the team apart.

New England were playing so badly that people stopped showing up to Gillette Stadium – the seats were noticeably emptier. The first try for a new era was a disaster. Mayo was let go.

Everything you need to know about Super Bowl LX

After two consecutive seasons with the worst record in franchise history, New England tried again. Complacency had no place in Foxborough. On January 12, 2025, they announced the hiring of Mike Vrabel as their new head coach.

Vrabel wasted no time. His message was simple: one aggressive offseason could change everything. 

He already had a foundation: young quarterback Drake Maye, elite cornerback Christian Gonzalez, and a handful of other impact players. More importantly, the Patriots entered free agency with over $120 million in cap space - nearly $30 million more than any other team. And they were willing to spend.

We went 4-13. We have to have results,” Patriots executive vice president of player personnel Eliot Wolf said. “We need to continue to improve the roster.”

They signed defensive end Milton Williams to a four-year deal, added defensive tackle Khyiris Tonga, and brought in linebackers Harold Landry and K’Lavon Chaisson. Tonga and Chaisson arrived on modest contracts but quickly earned major roles. 

On offence, the Patriots landed star receiver Stefon Diggs, veteran tackle Morgan Moses, and centre Garrett Bradbury, all immediate starters.

The franchise brought in 19 free agents and spent $364.4 million on them. It was a major investment, but critically needed if the team wanted to compete for the title again.

We feel really excited about some of the names that we’ve added. We still know there’s a lot of work to be done,” Wolf said.

They added more depth via their draft picks, and it was a ridiculously good draft. The leadership selected 11 players, and they all appeared in games during the season and remain on the active roster.

Will Campbell, a left tackle from LSU, has made a tremendous impact and has been a starter from the beginning of the year. “Adding Will to our football team is about a foundational piece, a young 21-year-old that's mature beyond his years,” Vrabel said. “He's a leader. He's durable. He's physical, dependable, and accountable. This was a very, very easy pick for us.”

But it wasn’t just about adding talent. New England brought in players who fit Vrabel’s system and mindset. The defence became aggressive, physical, and tough; the offence was fearless, poised, and precise.

When Vrabel took the job, he made it clear that he unconditionally trusted Drake Maye. He saw something in him that Maye probably didn’t even see in himself. Vrabel worked with him. Simplified play calls. Started games with easy throws to build his confidence up. And gave him complete freedom.

Under Vrabel, there was no playing scared. No conservative game management. He was bold. Aggressive. He built the team around Maye’s strengths. And trusted his guys to make good decisions.

Vrabel’s trust and brilliant playbook came into fruition right away. The Patriots finished the regular season with the third-best offence in the NFL, trailing only the Rams in points per game. They led the league in rushing yards.

Maye thrived under pressure, delivering veteran-level performances and highlight-reel plays throughout the year. He was named an MVP finalist, narrowly losing to Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford in one of the closest races in league history.

Super Bowl LX by the numbers

Of course, the defence has tremendously improved as well. It was tough, physical, relentless. The Patriots were one of nine teams that held their opponents to less than 20 points per game on average.

And just like that, the Patriots were back in the game, shooting for the AFC East title again. After starting the season 1–2, they rattled off ten straight wins before Buffalo finally handed them a loss in Week 15. It was only their third - and final - defeat of the season.

As the No. 2 seed, the Patriots rolled past the Chargers in the Wild Card Round, eliminated Houston in the Divisional Round, and then faced the top-seeded Denver Broncos in the AFC Championship Game. In blizzard-like conditions, they outlasted Denver to punch their ticket to the Super Bowl.

They are now going to face the Seattle Seahawks in a showdown predicted to be neck-to-neck.

I think we'll be much more competitive this year,” said Wolf before the season kicked off. “I don't like to put expectations on it, but I think we did a lot of things this offseason that were advantageous to us moving forward.”

That was a major understatement. Vrabel achieved a remarkable turnaround in just his first season. He was voted the Coach of the Year, rightfully so.

Before the 2025 season, the Patriots had no business dreaming of a Super Bowl. Instead, they became the first team in league history to reach the championship game after losing 13 games the previous year. Vrabel’s resurgence proved that the right combination of system, players, and trust can change everything. He added courage, boldness, and belief. New England played fast, exciting, nothing-to-lose football—and it paid off.

Now, the team will have a chance to lift the Lombardi Trophy. It would be the cherry on top of the fastest and greatest turnaround in NFL history. From rock bottom all the way to the mountain top.

But the Patriots will make history either way. If they win, they will have the most Super Bowl wins as a franchise; they are currently tied at six with the Steelers. If they lose, they will become a team with the most Super Bowl losses. Either way, this season will be one for the books.

Follow the Super Bowl with Flashscore

Chances are you’re about to lose.

For free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au